THOMISM.COM

A Scholastic Guide to Confession: Ensuring Validity

Part 1. Preliminary Notions

Christian B. Wagner's avatar
Christian B. Wagner
Nov 17, 2026
∙ Paid

Introduction

For many Catholics, there are a number of different questions about confession that they want answered. Unfortunately, answers are difficult to come by. Even when they ask a priest (whether inside or outside the confessional), it often happens that the priest himself is not sure, his answer is not clear, or you suspect that he was shooting from the hip by formulating his own opinion on the spot. This is why the Church has developed over the past few centuries various styles of theology that are meant to answer such questions precisely. This precision can take some time to digest, but you can be assured that the answers that are given are answers that are accepted by a great number of theologians, priests, saints, and members of the hierarchy over multiple centuries. While there are quite niche questions where there are debates between theologians, these are usually the sort of questions that people don’t really ask about or need to know about. Unlike some other topics in theology, there is broad (practical) agreement among theologians on some of the most important questions about the confessional.

In order to treat this topic properly, I will treat it across nine articles, of which this is the first. While each article can be read by itself to give answers to questions about confession, they also build upon each other, with later articles elucidating in more detail what is treated in earlier articles in order to give a systematic presentation of what is useful for laymen to know about confession. Each section will begin with a listing of various classical sources where these questions are treated for those who wish to look into these topics in greater detail. There will also be extensive endnotes quoting sections from these theologians, especially where there is disagreement or a more speculative question.

I (usually) have my own opinion where there is debate between theologians, but I will be sure to note this disagreement in the body of the article where there is no consensus and further reading can be done by checking out the recommended sources (especially Doronzo) and the footnotes.

This series is specifically concerned with what is being confessed and how, but it would be a mistake to conclude that following what is said here is sufficient on its own for a valid and fruitful confession. To merely state your sins with the most exact and extensive examination of conscience is not sufficient to be validly absolved. There are various dispositions required on the part of the penitent. In this series, I will not be treating those aspects of confession (I gave a brief treatment of this here), but will be focusing on what sins need to be confessed and how.

Throughout this series, I will give an exhaustive treatment of whatever needs to be known about what you must confess, what details must be given in confession, how to give them, when confessions must be repeated, what happens if you “mess up” your confession or cannot remember your sins, and many questions in between.

There are nine articles planned for this series:

  1. Was My Confession Valid?

  2. How to Confess the Number of Sins

  3. How Much Detail Do I Have to Give?

  4. Do I Have to Confess a Sin I’m Not Sure I Committed?

  5. Why You Should Confess More than Mortal Sins

  6. What Happens if I Forget a Sin in Confession?

  7. When Do I Have to Confess a Sin Again?

  8. When Do I Have to Go to Confession?

  9. How to Make a Good Confession

In this series I want to home in on one particular aspect of confession that is often vaguely presented by catechists, pastors, etc., and to treat it from authoritative sources of theology.

The first article is meant to lay the foundation for the rest. Here, the theological principles will be laid down, along with the general answers of the validity and integrity of confession that will be applied throughout this series. This is crucial to understanding the rest.

NOTE. These articles will be released one per week going forward. If you want to follow along with the series, please consider becoming a FREE subscriber by clicking the join button below. If you become a paid subscriber, then you will also have access to additional notes at the end of each article in this series!

A Note to the Scrupulous

Please stop reading if you are (truly) scrupulous. If you have genuine scrupulosity that makes confession extraordinarily difficult, I am warning you that it is poison to study these matters in detail during an episode (although it will help you outside of these times). With the help of a regular confessor to whom you submit completely and without question, you can overcome scrupulosity.

On the other hand, for many of you, while you may think you have scrupulosity, you do not. It is extraordinarily common to falsely identify oneself as a scrupulant. You may have a delicate conscience or have scruples without being a scrupulant. For you, this article will be of great help in fruitfully putting your delicate conscience to good use. In fact, I truly believe that a thorough and technical knowledge of such matters is a guard against falling into scrupulosity.

If you want to read more about genuine scrupulosity, check out St. Alphonsus’ treatment of this matter (Theologia Moralis, lib. I, nn. 11-19). It is important for me to emphasize again that many of you who believe that you have scrupulosity are not scrupulants. For those with tendencies for scruples or a delicate conscience, this study will help you guard against scrupulosity. I do not ask these to stop reading, but encourage them to study with zeal. This also applies to those who have scrupulosity, but have made progress and are not in an episode. Even so, be circumspect: always receive permission from your confessor and keep him updated.

Throughout this article, I will give notes on scrupulosity and how each of these matters relates to the scrupulous. I do not do this as if I believe an active scrupulant could read such an article and be ordinarily helped by this study. I do this because I am aware that there are seminarians and priests who read my articles, along with seminary professors and those who could become seminary professors one day. These individuals need a thorough study of such matters. It is also useful for the man who is not a scrupulant, either as a foil or as knowledge that will be helpful if he begins to slide into scrupulosity.

As a final note, do not let your false self-diagnosis become an excuse for laxity. Laxity and tepidity will destroy your soul faster than scrupulosity ever could. Many of the notes for scrupulants concern recommendations that are less rigid than what is recommended for others due to the extraordinary situation that they find themselves in. If that is not you, it is discouraged (or, in some cases, even immoral) to follow such recommendations.

What “Must” Means

SOURCES: St. Thomas, Suppl., q. 6, aa. 1–6; Quodl. I, aa. 10–12. Doronzo, De Poenitentia II, a. 37 (pp. 464–541). St. Alphonsus, Theologia Moralis VI, nn. 662 ff. Suárez, De poenitentia, disp. 21; Lugo, De poenitentia, disp. 15.

In ordinary language, terms like “can,” “should,” “must,” etc., are used without much regard for their formal meaning. There is nothing inherently strange or problematic with this. Yet, when we are discussing issues in sacramentology, it is certainly problematic to use these descriptors without some attention to what we are actually attempting to communicate.

For example, let’s say that I said “you need to have 6 months of preparation for marriage in this diocese.” What do I mean by “need”? I mean that it is something that is commanded by the relevant authorities in the diocese. On the other hand, let’s say “you need to have witnesses in order to be married.” With this, I don’t simply mean to indicate something that is commanded by certain authorities, I also mean something that is necessary for the existence or validity of the marriage.

From this brief example, we recognize that it is incumbent on us to clarify what we mean when describing confession. Is this necessary for validity? Is this necessary by law? Is this necessary for a good confession? Each of these can be confused if we are not careful enough with how we describe things. Therefore, while certain terms or phrases may sound repetitive, there is a reason for it.

In general, there are five senses that “must” can have in moral theology, which must be kept distinct. If these are confused with one another, a completely wrong conclusion can be drawn and, in some cases, it can lead to practical ruin. These senses are the following: (1) What is required for the validity of the sacrament, so that without it there is no absolution at all (i.e., matter, form, minister, intention); (2) What is commanded by divine precept, from which no one, not even the Pope, can dispense (St. Thomas, Suppl., q. 6, a. 6); (3) What is commanded by the law of the Church, which can be dispensed by the proper authorities (e.g., yearly confession); (4) What is practically necessary due to the ordinary state of penitents, but not strictly necessary; and, (5) What is merely counselled as the better thing, and not even practically necessary, which can, in certain cases, even be harmful per accidens.

Each of these things can be described as things we “must” do, which can be illustrated with a few examples. First, you must be contrite for a valid absolution, since contrition belongs to the matter of the sacrament. Second, you must tell every unconfessed mortal sin in number, species, and necessary circumstances by divine law, yet one who is inculpably ignorant of a mortal sin that he did not confess can be validly absolved. Third, you must confess at least once a year by the law of the Church. Fourth, you must confess all notably aggravating circumstances, even those that do not change the species (while it is probable that these circumstances need not be confessed, confessing them is practically necessary due to the difficulty that most penitents have in telling which circumstances change the species). Fifth, you must confess your venial sins or make a general confession (which is an excellent counsel that can be harmful per accidens, e.g., in the case of scrupulants).

In each of these five cases, the word “must” is used, yet they are functioning in five different ways. If any of these are confused, this can wrongly lead the faithful to conclude that their confessions are invalid or that they gravely sinned, when they simply left out a counsel, or vice-versa.

It will be important to disambiguate cases of the first from the other cases. Simply because what ought to be done is not done does not mean that the sacrament is not valid (except in cases where the violation is gravely culpable, i.e., a mortal sin committed in the confession itself, which necessarily invalidates the sacrament). It is also important to distinguish the fourth case from the second, third, and fifth. There are a handful of different cases where doing and not doing are each probable in themselves, yet for the ordinary layman, it is morally necessary that he do that act.

This is something that is especially important when it comes to confession since this could be the difference between having to repeat a confession and simply making a note for the future.

The Matter of the Sacrament

SOURCES: Council of Trent, sess. 14, cc. 3 and 5, cann. 4 and 7. 1917 Code, cann. 901–902; 1983 Code, can. 988. St. Thomas, III, q. 84, aa. 2–3; q. 90, a. 1; Suppl., q. 8, a. 5, ad 4; q. 18, a. 2, ad 4; In IV Sent., d. 16, q. 1, a. 2; d. 17, q. 3, a. 3, qc. 5, ad 4. Doronzo, De Poenitentia I, aa. 3–7 (pp. 156–229), especially a. 6 (pp. 209–211) and a. 7 (pp. 211–229); IV, a. 95, nota 8 (pp. 533–534). St. Alphonsus, Theologia Moralis VI, nn. 425–432; Homo Apostolicus, tr. XVI. Suárez, disp. 18, sect. 1; Lugo, disp. 13, sect. 3; Salmanticenses, Cursus theologicus, tr. 24, disp. 2, dub. 1; Billot, De poenitentia, thes. 5; Galtier, De paenitentia, nn. 457–460.

Every sacrament is constituted by matter and form. The form is applied to the matter in order to make a sacrament. Baptism has the Trinitarian formula and water; the Eucharist has the words of institution and bread and wine. In Penance, it is a bit more complicated. The form of Penance is the absolution of the priest, but the matter is different from the examples we have brought forward; in Penance, the matter that the form is applied to is certain acts of the penitent himself (contrition, confession, satisfaction). It is for this reason that Penance uniquely requires proper dispositions in the penitent in order to be valid. If a penitent is not truly contrite, then he is not validly absolved due to improper matter. A common example of this concerns the firm purpose of amendment; in many cases, the penitent does not intend to amend his life, avoiding all mortal sin and the proximate occasions of it.

While contrition was discussed in a previous article, in this series I want to deal with the second aspect of the matter, i.e., confession. When we consider sacraments, the matter can be twofold: the remote matter and the proximate matter (e.g., in baptism, the remote matter is water and the proximate matter is the pouring of the water). In Penance, the remote matter is the sins of the penitent, whereas the proximate matter is how these sins are acted upon by the penitent: contrition (the hatred of sin), confession (the declaration of sins), and satisfaction (the actions that remove the effects of sin). When these are presented to the priest externally, he applies the form (absolution) to the penitent, absolving him of his sins.

When it comes to the sacrament of penance, if there is an essential defect of the minister, intention, form, or matter, then it is invalid. Defect of minister would occur if the priest did not have jurisdiction to hear confessions and perform absolution (or, if the minister was not a priest). Defect of intention would occur if the priest did not intend to do what the Church does in absolving. Defect of form would occur if the absolution was not said properly with some essential defect (e.g., if the priest said only ‘May God forgive you’ and left out ‘I absolve you’). Defect of matter occurs when there is an essential defect in contrition, confession, or satisfaction. This would occur if the penitent is not truly contrite for his sins (e.g., he does not intend to amend his life), or if he does not confess as he is able to (e.g., if he deliberately avoids telling certain mortal sins without just cause), or does not intend to perform satisfaction (n.b., if the satisfaction is not in fact performed, then the confession is valid as long as he intended to perform it).

In this article, I wish to consider the remote matter insofar as it is the object of confession. When we consider the ‘remote matter’ (i.e., that upon which the sacrament acts, called materia circa quam by theologians), this is distinguished into necessary matter, free matter, and sufficient matter.

  • Sufficient matter: This includes anything that can be presented so that the absolution could be valid (e.g., a man who confesses venial sins can be absolved if he has no mortal sins to confess)

  • Necessary matter: This includes all those sins that must be submitted to the keys in confession, i.e., every mortal sin committed after Baptism and not yet directly remitted by confession (n.b., this includes sins that have been forgiven indirectly but have not yet been integrally confessed, which will be explained below).

  • Free matter: This includes all those sins that can be submitted to the keys without an obligation to submit them to the keys (i.e., venial sins and mortal sins already confessed)

Either necessary matter or free matter is sufficient matter insofar as it is sufficient for absolution in itself; although, it may not be sufficient here and now if a man has necessary matter to confess and attempts to merely present free matter. To put it in other words, some sin is required and any sin suffices (sufficient matter), while certain sins must be confessed (necessary matter). All and only mortal sins not yet confessed are necessary matter, while every mortal sin already confessed and every venial sin whatsoever is free matter. Sometimes, we also distinguish between principal matter (mortal sin) and secondary matter (venial sins), which will be explained in the fifth article of this series.

One practical consequence of this division is that one should always present what is certainly sufficient matter. If someone goes to confession and only presents doubtful sins or only presents imperfections, then the absolution is null or doubtful for want of certain matter (and to seek it knowingly would be sacrilegious). Therefore, it is always a good idea when one doubts whether sufficient matter is present to confess some certain sin that has already been confessed and absolved, or some certain venial sin. [1]

NOTE: When we call sins the “matter” of the sacrament, we mean it in the sense of remote matter, just as we call water the matter of baptism as the remote matter. Do not conclude from this that it is possible for sins alone, without acts of the penitent, to be absolved by the application of the form to them. In order for sins to be apt for absolution, they have to be acted upon in order to make it proximate matter, just as baptismal water must be applied to the one being baptized, without which baptism would be impossible. Sins are only the matter of the sacrament as the object of the penitent’s contrition and confession, and where these are absent there cannot be a sacrament. Therefore, the dying man cannot be absolved absolutely unless he gives some external sign of sorrow (where it is doubtful whether he has given one, he is absolved conditionally).

The Integrity of Confession

SOURCES: Council of Trent, sess. 14, c. 5 and can. 7 (DH 1679–1683, 1707). St. Thomas, Suppl., q. 9, a. 2; q. 10, a. 5; In IV Sent., d. 16, q. 3, a. 2, qc. 5. Doronzo, De Poenitentia II, a. 39 (pp. 544–687): the state of the question (pp. 544–546) and Conclusions 1–3 (pp. 552–564). St. Alphonsus, Theologia Moralis VI, nn. 465 and 479; Homo Apostolicus, tr. XVI. Suárez, disp. 22, sect. 1–2; Lugo, disp. 16, sect. 1–2; Salmanticenses, tr. 24, disp. 8, dub. 1–2; Gonet, Clypeus, De poenitentia, disp. 10; Billuart, De poenitentia, diss. 7, a. 2. Prümmer, III, nn. 362 ff.; Merkelbach, III, nn. 517 ff.; Cappello, De poenitentia, nn. 134–211; Aertnys-Damen, II, nn. 291–305; Regatillo-Zalba, III, nn. 535–555; Concina, Theologia christiana dogmatico-moralis IX, lib. I, diss. 4, cap. 4; Patuzzi, Ethica christiana VI, cap. 3; Mezger, Theologia scholastica III, tract. 18, disp. 47, a. 3; Reding, Theologia scholastica VII, q. 9, a. 2; Tanquerey, Synopsis theologiae moralis, De poenitentia, nn. 254 and 295–301; Konings, Theologia moralis, n. 1367.

The integrity of confession is its completeness relative to its necessary matter. This is distinct from both the validity (i.e., did the sacrament truly happen) and liceity (i.e., did the sacrament happen legally) of confession. Unfortunately, many simply consider the question of validity or liceity vis-à-vis confession, but integrity is also a significant question that may ground an obligation to confess sins that were previously absolved (indirectly). Therefore, Pope Alexander VII condemned the following proposition: “We are not bound to express in a following confession sins omitted or forgotten in confession because of pressing danger to life or for another cause” (DH 2031).

Material integrity is a completeness that consists of confessing every sin that per se must be submitted to the sacrament (i.e., every mortal sin committed after Baptism that has not yet been confessed). This kind of integrity is rarely reached outside of a few cases (e.g., someone who is baptized later in life and confesses frequently). One of the reasons for this lack of material integrity (besides simply forgetting mortal sins) is the fact that those sins that are invalidly confessed, or confessed with some sort of defect (e.g., not consisting of the correct number or a sufficiently specific species, relevant circumstance, etc.) must also be confessed for material integrity.

Formal integrity is a completeness that consists of confessing every sin that a penitent can and must accuse himself of here and now, i.e., every sin from whose accusation he is not legitimately excused for the moment. Since men have imperfections of mind and body that make the confession of every mortal sin committed after Baptism that has not yet been confessed impossible, formal integrity does not always coincide with material integrity.

It is to be noted that there is a range of terminology employed by moralists in order to describe this distinction. Some moralists call material integrity “objective” and formal integrity “subjective,” since material integrity indicates what must, abstractly speaking, be done, while formal integrity indicates what the penitent, concretely, can and must do here and now (e.g., Cappello, De poenitentia, n. 141; Tanquerey, n. 254).

What is required for the validity of confession is formal integrity, which is always present when nothing is left out of one’s confession through one’s own grave fault (i.e., when “nothing is kept back in bad faith”; Aertnys-Damen, II, n. 291). It is for this reason that the Church makes qualifications when describing the integrity of confession. The 1983 Code of Canon Law speaks of the grave sins “of which the person has knowledge after diligent examination of conscience” (Can. 988 §1) and Trent variously speaks of “all the mortal sins, of which, after a diligent examination of themselves, they are conscious” (Sess. 14, cap. v), “all the sins which occur to their memory” (ibid.), “mortal sins which after due and diligent previous meditation are remembered” (ibid., can. vii), and it uses this to answer the Protestant objection to the requirement of integrity in confession:

“Nothing else is required of penitents, but that, after each has examined himself diligently, and searched all the folds and recesses of his conscience, he confess those sins by which he shall remember that he has mortally offended his Lord and God: whilst the other sins, which do not occur to him after diligent thought, are understood to be included as a whole in that same confession.” (Ibid., cap. v)

On this point, there is complete agreement among Catholic theologians. If one performs a diligent examination and cannot remember a mortal sin, then this is forgiven by the sacrament indirectly. There is no obligation whatsoever to go to heroic lengths in trying to conjure up sins, but a proportionate and serious examination suffices to be free from any accusation of negligence.

Fr. Suárez writes that the validity of confession is preserved when there is “a confession of all the sins for which no excuse intervenes.” (De poenitentia, disp. 22, prooem.) Cardinal Lugo writes that, for validity, “what is required is the formal integrity of confession, not the material: that is, that all things be told, so far as can be done.” (De Eucharistia, disp. 14, sect. 5) St. Alphonsus writes that, for validity, a confession does not need to be materially integral “provided that it be so formally or morally, that is, as far as it morally can be here and now.” (Theologia Moralis VI, n. 479) Fr. Patuzzi gives the reason, writing that “if material integrity cannot be had, formal integrity suffices… for God does not command impossible things.” (Ethica christiana VI, cap. 3, n. 6) This is commonly taught and there are no dissenters. [2]

The physical or moral impotence that causes this difference between what is necessary for material integrity and what is necessary for formal integrity may be something that is permanent (e.g., inability to speak) or it may be something that is temporary (e.g., temporary loss of memory). If it is temporary, then it only applies as long as the impotence lasts, with the concrete obligation to confess properly once the impotence has been removed (e.g., someone in danger of death who confesses quickly and recovers must again confess in species and number as far as he is able to when recovered); if it is permanent, then the abstract obligation to confess these sins properly remains, but it is never concrete. Further, the physical or moral impotence that causes this may be either entire (e.g., intense scrupulosity) or it may be partial (e.g., inculpable ignorance of a previously committed mortal sin). Where the physical or moral impotence is partial, the exception goes only as far as the impotence does (e.g., the man who is invincibly ignorant of one sin is still required to confess another for formal integrity): he is required to confess, in species and number, all the sins which the moral or physical impotence does not touch. [3]

While these distinctions may seem unimportant, they help explain a perpetual problem that many Catholics have vis-à-vis confession. When we give due diligence to the task of finding out these sins, it happens more often than not that we make some mistakes in this process, often misremembering the number or leaving out a sin. In fact, nearly every confession lacks material integrity since this includes ALL unconfessed mortal sins after baptism, even those from decades earlier. This being the case, we judge the errors that arise in this process like we do any other precept. Is the gravity of the fault light or grave? Was the fault culpable or inculpable? For most of us who spend some time examining our consciences, any faults in recounting our mortal sins are either inculpable or they are due to light faults. In this case, there is complete ‘formal integrity’ even while there is an incomplete ‘material integrity.’

On this point, it should be remembered that some things required in confession do not invalidate it when omitted through inculpable ignorance, while others do so whether we are inculpably ignorant or not. For example, let’s assume that some person was somehow ignorant of the fact that he needed to give the number of mortal sins and every priest simply assumed he was confessing only venial sins for years. Were his confessions invalid all those years? It depends. If he was culpably ignorant in so grave a matter, his confessions would be invalid, but if he was inculpably ignorant, then his confessions would be valid if there is formal integrity and everything else requisite for the validity of the sacrament is present (i.e., the form, minister, true contrition, etc.). While the other elements are invalidating even if excluded by inculpable ignorance (i.e., form, minister, formal integrity of confession, true contrition, etc.), the material integrity of confession is not one of them.

Therefore, when asking the question of the obligation to repeat confessions, there are two questions that need to be asked. First, where was there a lack of material integrity? On each of those essential points, even if it was excluded from confession by legitimate excuse, there remains an obligation to confess. Second, where was there invalidity? In such a case, the entire confession needs to be repeated since none of the sins were absolved. [4]

This is important to note for those who struggle with the fact that they often forget sins during their examination of conscience. If you carry out your examination without any gravely culpable defect (i.e., with the amount of time and diligence necessary for a serious task) and confess every mortal sin you recall, then you have formal integrity. If the formal integrity of confession is preserved even if the impotence of a man is so great that he can only make gestures of his contrition without a single word, why can’t it be preserved in your case when you make a diligent and serious examination?

Yet, remember that, alongside this, there is a moral obligation to confess all mortal sins with material integrity (number, species, necessary circumstances); therefore, where there is inculpable omission, the sin is absolved, but you still have the obligation to confess the sin once you recall it. To give an example, let’s say that you examined your conscience and found that you had mortally sinned by theft; but, when you go to confession, you are so nervous that you forget this sin and receive absolution. If this is inculpable or only lightly culpable, then the sin is absolved, but you still have to state it the next time you go to confession.

NOTE 1. This is why the Church strongly recommends the practice of general confessions. It may happen that there are a number of different sins that were passed over in confession without you remembering or invalid confessions that you believe in good faith were actually valid. Your obligation towards these cannot extend further than your memory. In a general confession, you sit down and think through your entire life since your baptism and confess the mortal sins that you can remember from the top down. If you sit down and diligently record everything you can remember, obviously anything that was done improperly is covered and whatever is not remembered is invincibly forgotten.

It is to be noted that general confessions are NOT to be permitted to scrupulants, or anyone else who unreasonably fears the invalidity of their past confessions. There is plenty of room for reasonably fearing the invalidity or incompleteness of your confessions (e.g., you did not state number for years, did not do any examination of conscience for years, etc.), but unreasonable fears will destroy true peace of conscience.

General confessions will be treated at length in a later article.

NOTE 2. Certain catechetical materials will frequently only mention the deliberate concealing of sins as invalidating confessions. While this is one act that can destroy formal integrity and require re-confession, this is not the only one. For example, if you omit your examination of conscience through grave fault when it is gravely necessary, you do not have a formally integral confession; if you through grave fault omit or change the number or circumstances in necessary matter, the same applies. Any act that is gravely culpable destroys the formal integrity of confession and requires re-confession. The same does not apply for acts that are lightly culpable (e.g., doing one’s examination quicker than he should, but not to such a degree as to gravely endanger his ability to examine). The same also does not apply to acts that are per se grave, but are done inculpably (e.g., you are invincibly ignorant of the obligation to examine your conscience before confession).

An “Acceptable” Violation of Confession’s Integrity

SOURCES: Roman Catechism, II, c. 5. St. Thomas, Suppl., q. 6, a. 4 (especially ad 3); q. 9, a. 4; II-II, q. 69, aa. 1–2. Doronzo, De Poenitentia II, a. 38 (pp. 541–544) and a. 39, nota 9 (pp. 605–607). St. Alphonsus, Theologia Moralis VI, nn. 495–497; Homo Apostolicus, tr. XVI, n. 28. Suárez, De poenitentia, disp. 22, sect. 10; Lugo, De poenitentia, disp. 16, sect. 2, §6 (nn. 98 ff.); Salmanticenses, tr. 24, disp. 8, dub. 8 (nn. 256 ff.). Sylvester Prierias, Summa, v. Confessio I, n. 9. Concina, Theologia christiana dogmatico-moralis IX, lib. I, diss. 4, cap. 3, q. 1; Patuzzi, Ethica christiana VI, cap. 3, nn. 1–2. Aertnys-Damen, II, n. 309; Marc, Institutiones morales Alphonsianae II, n. 1689; Cappello, De poenitentia, n. 134; Merkelbach, III, nn. 525 ff.; Noldin, De sacramentis, n. 269; Wouters, n. 324; Tanquerey, Synopsis theologiae moralis, De poenitentia, nn. 290–291; Gury-Ballerini, II, n. 474.

Here, it is important to speak against an abominable practice that some engage in to vainly comfort themselves by petty lies in so solemn a matter. This violation is seen as not only acceptable, but even pious. While many speak of concealing sins as a violation of the integrity of confession, it is also true that penitents who invent sins in order to be “on the safe side” violate the integrity of confession, stating as certain that which is doubtful, increasing the number to account for a possible lapse in memory, etc. This should be avoided at all costs as a sacrilegious act since, as St. Alphonsus notes, it is far worse than a simple lie, violating truthfulness by falsehood and religion by sacrilege (Theologia Moralis VI, n. 497).

Taken in itself, the act is grave as an act of sacrilege. This is something that is commonly taught by Catholic theologians. Yet, it may happen in certain cases (i.e., when it is done from simplicity, scruple, disturbance of mind, etc.) that this is excused from mortal sin. Some authors even say that this is what happens in the majority of instances (Marc, Institutiones morales Alphonsianae II, n. 1689; Cappello, De poenitentia, n. 134). Yet, when this is done knowingly and deliberately, then it is a grave lie and sacrilege. In practice, penitents rarely do this knowingly and deliberately and incur only slight fault or none, yet those who are reading this right now have been informed of the evils of this practice. Therefore, do not scruple about your past confessions where you did this, but avoid it in the future.

While it is often excused from grave sin when culpability is lessened, this perversion of false humility and security should be avoided at all costs. It feeds into scruples and destroys the foundations of true repentance. Truly and honestly state the number of sins as best you can approximate it. When you are doubtful of a sin, state it as doubtful; as St. Thomas says, the penitent “ought not to assert that it is mortal, but to speak doubtingly, and to await the judgment of the priest” (Suppl., q. 6, a. 4, ad 3). Do not try to “err on the safe side” since intentional error is lying, which is always against the moral law.

Fr. Suárez gives us clearer details of this matter (De poenitentia, disp. 22, sect. 10). He states that a man can lie in confession in two ways: by denying what he did, or by affirming what he did not do; further, the lie may be about three things: circumstances that have nothing to do with the confession, free matter, and necessary matter (ibid., n. 2). In this case, we are treating lying about the third object in the second way.

As to the first kind of thing, “it is not a mortal sin, nor against the validity of confession, to mix in some lie, whether by affirming or by denying; but it is a venial sin, and a graver one than a like lie would be outside that act.” (ibid., n. 3)

To lie about the second kind of thing is commonly held to be a venial sin (and, according to many, a graver one than the same lie outside the sacrament), unless a falsely accused venial sin is presented as the only matter, in which case the sin is grave and the sacrament is null (cf. St. Alphonsus, Theologia Moralis VI, nn. 495–496; Doronzo, De Poenitentia II, a. 39, nota 9). A few authors hold that it is mortal even apart from that case, on account of the irreverence shown to the sacrament (Cajetan), or at least doubt whether it is simply a venial fault (Concina). [5] Yet, it should be noted that this hardly ever happens and would almost necessarily either involve contempt or some mitigating factor. [6]

To lie about the third kind of thing in a negative manner, denying that one has committed a mortal sin, or that it had some necessary circumstance, etc., “is always mortal and against the substance of the sacrament.” (ibid., n. 10) This is agreed upon by all. The difficulty concerns the affirmative lie, although Suárez finds only Sylvester suggesting the contrary of the common teaching, which holds that this is grave as well. Here are the reasons that Suárez gives:

In itself, and setting aside invincible ignorance, this is a mortal sin, and consequently against the substance of the sacrament… The ground is that this is matter of grave sacrilege. Its gravity is shown, first, from the fact that it is a deception in the necessary matter of the sacrament. Second, because in every judgment a lie in what belongs to the substance of the cause, deceiving the judge in it, is a mortal sin. Third, because in this way the whole knowledge which the confessor receives of the penitent’s conscience, as to the number or the species of his mortal sins, would be made very uncertain; nor would penitents be bound to examine their conscience so as to give a definite number, since they could increase it at will without mortal sin… This resolution is to be understood of the matter in itself. For where ignorance and good faith come in, it is clear that the penitent can be without sin in this, and consequently can make a valid confession; and in this way many simple people can be excused, who think that they do no wrong in saying more than they did. (ibid., n. 11)

For those who are aware of the rule and lie anyway, the excuse of simplicity is not available. Therefore, moralists state simply that it is mortal for those who do this knowingly:

He sins gravely who knowingly confesses a mortal sin which he did not commit; or who knowingly increases the number of his mortal sins, unless he should do this from simplicity; likewise he who knowingly confesses a doubtful sin as certain, or the reverse; or who denies that he is a habitual sinner, a relapsing sinner, or in an occasion of sin, when in truth he is; because he notably vitiates the judgment of the confessor in a grave matter. (Aertnys-Damen, Theologia Moralis II, n. 309; cf. Noldin, De sacramentis, n. 269)

Conclusion

This article lays the groundwork for the entire series, which is going to elucidate the meaning of the principle that “it is of divine law that every mortal sin committed since baptism be confessed in species, number, and necessary circumstances,” whether explaining what the terms mean, how far they apply, or how to practically present them in confession.

Below are some notes that I added which explain many of these points in greater detail. If you are a paid subscriber, you can get access to these!

Although, before that, I want to insert an appendix on a point that didn’t really fit anywhere in the article without serious digression.

Appendix. A Theological Explanation of the Necessity of Material and Formal Integrity

To understand better the distinction between material and formal integrity, note that material integrity of confession is not one of those things that are (in the words of the theologians) necessary by a necessity of means per se (as is the case for contrition, charity, sanctifying grace, faith, etc.) or necessary by a necessity of means per accidens (as is the case for explicit faith in the Trinity/Incarnation, sacramental baptism, membership in the Catholic Church, etc.), but only necessary by a necessity of precept. Contrition is necessary by a necessity of means per se (hence, indispensable for all adults), formal integrity is necessary by a necessity of means per accidens (therefore, an explicit or implicit desire must be included in contrition, as is the case with implicit faith vis-à-vis faith in the Trinity and Incarnation, baptism of desire vis-à-vis sacramental baptism, and implicit desire of union with the Church vis-à-vis membership in the Catholic Church), and material integrity is necessary by a necessity of precept.

Therefore, in cases of moral or physical impotence, material integrity is NOT necessary. If you are inculpably ignorant of unconfessed mortal sins after baptism or there is simply not time to recount them (e.g., danger of death), formal integrity suffices. Therefore, even in extreme cases where the externalization of contrition over sin is certain without number and species (e.g., of a man merely telling the priest that he has mortally sinned and expressing some contrition) and there is moral or physical impotence to add any further degree of material integrity, absolute absolution can be given. Where this is doubtful, conditional absolution can be given. [7]

Corollary. Since the material integrity of confession is something that is only necessary by a necessity of precept, the manner in which opinions are formed and followed related to it are quite different than the manner in which opinions are formed and followed related to the validity of a sacrament. In questions concerning the material integrity of the sacrament, probable opinions can be followed, e.g., I can follow as a probable opinion that notably aggravating circumstances do not need to be confessed. On the other hand, when it concerns the validity of sacraments, I cannot follow a probable opinion, e.g., a priest cannot categorically absolve a penitent who probably lacks true contrition. (cf. Tanquerey, Synopsis theologiae moralis et pastoralis, vol. I, n. 258)

Notes

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Christian B. Wagner.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Christian B. Wagner · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.