30 Comments
User's avatar
David de Maistre's avatar

Actions speak more than words. The Society will go on with the consecrations, having been warned that they constitute schism, and Don Davide refused the offer even to postpone them so that real doctrinal dialogue may ensue. I don't think that can be squared with true filial piety and Catholic obedience. And I don't think it's useful discourse which paints the two sides as if their were in equal footing, which they're not. One of them is the supreme authority of the Catholic Church.

Christian B. Wagner's avatar

There are, of course, two sides to not delaying the consecrations. They have been reaching out for nearly a year to meet with His Holiness. Further, the a sort of delay tactics were done with the original consecrations that left a bad taste in their mouths. On the other hand, Rome knows that the talks are going to be unsuccessful, as they were under Francis.

These matters and the personal motivations involved are more complicated than you can imagine and there is much that we do not know. While the theological judgement may be simple (I do believe this constitutes an act of schism and a canonical crime), pretending as if we can construct some narrative about one side being the “good guy” and the other side the “bad guy” is naive—neither Rome nor the Soceity thinks it is that simple.

Fr. John Lovell's avatar

Excellent analysis, Christian. I would add that the Holy Father sending this letter at the eleventh hour comes across as disingenuous. I commend Fr P for such a quick response!

Chris Mah's avatar

Any more than the timing of the consecrations just over a year into Leo's Papacy. Neither of their Bishops are critically ill. Or the SSPX's last minute drop of a very long statement of faith a week before the consecrations. A rather inflammatory one at that.

Wagner hinted at this but the SSPX have had opportunities to talk since Saint Paul VI.

David de Maistre's avatar

There is none good but God. That we can agree. But it’s not true that Rome used delay tactics in the ‘88. That’s what Lefebvre thought because confidence had been broken (and several Vatican officials had guilt for that), but Ratzinger was the one responsible for the talks and we know he was not a deceitful person. And Rome presented a final offer for consecrations on 15 August ‘88. So it’s not true that Rome did not give a specific date.

Nick Cardone's avatar

Thank you for this, Mr Wagner.

As someone very who is completely on board with the Society, it is very tempting to want to find personal problems in one’s ideological opponents. It’s always good to remind ourselves that people don’t usually want bad things to happen for the evil’s sake, and even if we think someone is in the wrong, it doesn’t mean we have to think they have some sort of fundamentally evil character to them.

May God bless you.

B B's avatar

I don't totally get the kid gloves here. If this is schism as you've said in a comment it is what does it matter how nicely it's said. The sin is extremely grave not to mention the scandal. Sure the language in the letters isn't outright vicious but seems important to very clearly call a spade a spade here rather than laud the sheep's clothing on the wolves

Scholastic Servant's avatar

Well see what happens tomorrow

Antonio's avatar

I feel bad for the people following them since their sacraments will have the same validation as a Renaissance Fair wedding. They have deceived their sheep and taken them to dark pastures.

Spartacus ✨️🤝💪's avatar

Les partisans de messe tridentine, pour les avoir - fréquenté de près - sont des individus d’un autre âge, reclus, arriérés, rétrogrades,… bêtes.

Ignotus Amicus's avatar

I am the pope’s good subject, but Christ’s first.

Rex Amadeus's avatar

Do not ape a saint without understanding. You cannot divide Christ from his vicar.

Ignotus Amicus's avatar

I’m not the one dividing themselves from Christ. Peter is capable of that himself, as Scripture demonstrates.

Rex Amadeus's avatar

When Peter fell all the apostles fell. So why will you stand?

Ignotus Amicus's avatar

St John did not fall. He was with Our Lady at the foot of the Cross. I am able to stand because the God-bearer does.

Davizz Solaire's avatar

I also got impressed by the anwer. In fact, The next answer by Holy Father is going to define the future. God bless the Pope. God Bless his church.