Another fantastic article, Wagner. What a brilliant takedown of Jay's debate tactics. By explaining why challenging his opponents to demonstrate their first principles is foolhardy, you reveal his intellectual dishonesty.
Christian, you have confused indemonstrable metaphysical first principles with the demonstrable credibility of divine revelation. The principle of non-contradiction is self-evident; the claim that God revealed a particular religion is not simply declared a first principle and exempted from proof.
Catholic faith rests upon God’s authority, but reason must first establish the motives of credibility by which His revelation and Church are identified. Remove that demonstrability and every sect can call its own assumptions “first principles.” That does not defend the Faith—it makes rational certainty about the true Faith impossible.
The Thomistic school explains the credibility of divine revelation via discursive reasoning. We seek to prove the existence of God, particularly the Christian God, from first principles common to every man. Certain detractors often comment that the “Thomistic system” cannot give an epistemological account for a system based on first principles. This article addresses these claims and defends the practice of reasoning from these first principles, which is said to be unjustified. The article in no way claims that proving the first principle automatically proves God. It is a response to a neo-transcendentalist line of argumentation that denies the validity of a certain type of argument, because they think that simply presupposing the thing in question amounts to a profound and serious argument. I’m not sure what you’re objecting to here.
Nicholas, my objection is not to reasoning from self-evident first principles; on that we agree. It is to extending their indemonstrability to the identity of divine revelation itself.
The principle of noncontradiction is immediately known. That Christianity—and specifically the Catholic Faith—is God’s revelation must be established through demonstrable motives of credibility. If your article preserves that distinction, then my criticism concerns a misuse of its argument, not the argument you intended.
It’s not my article, and the article never claims that to defend Thomistic epistemology amounts to conclusively defending the Catholic faith. That is an absurd proposition, and I’m confused as to how you could think that the article even attempts to make that point.
Nicholas, your correction is well taken. Upon rereading Wagner’s essay, I agree that I attributed to it a thesis it neither states nor entails. Its subject is the indemonstrability—strictly understood—of metaphysical first principles and their dialectical defense against skepticism, not the sufficiency of those principles to establish the truth of Catholic revelation.
The distinction I raised remains necessary in fundamental theology: the act of faith rests formally upon divine authority, while reason establishes the motives of credibility by which a purported revelation is identified as genuinely divine. But Wagner does not deny that distinction, and therefore my criticism did not engage the argument he was actually making.
I also incorrectly referred to the essay as yours. On both points, I stand corrected and withdraw the objection.
Wagner isn't saying that nondemonstrable truths immediately prove thomist doctrines, those issues are alltogether different matters. So I fail to see what is even the point being made by Dyer, if this is his argument
So the parapetetic axiom is proved in the principle of non contradiction, which is the only first principle, because the intellect has to be operational, which means it has to have knowledge, and that knowledge had to come from the senses? I.e. words themselves, which were taught through the senses? What of a baby? Does it know the principle of non contradiction? How would it know this? A general sense? or is the knowledge of this principle acquired at the age of reason? does an animal know this principle?
What is the explanation for why or how is it proved (thinking of objectors here) that being is prior to our apprehension about being? is it because the world existed before we did? how do we know that? (pardon a stupid question)
Thank you for addressing Jay Dyer. Very helpful. I was put into a temptation of faith because of the lack of depth of Catholic apologetical debators. I am continually confronted on things like the Trinity by Muslims and atheists and others, even though I focus on economics, because that's what they want to talk about. And Dyer seemed better for the Trinity than any Catholics I'd heard. I try to focus on economics. Tomorrow, regardless, out of charity, I have to discuss the Trinity publicly with a Muslim, and I do feel unprepared.
But this isn’t the point made by Jay - yes he argues that you presuppose your own principle but he also argues that your first principle is superfluous. If Jay grants you the principle of non contradiction you have to demonstrate how that leads to Thomistic doctrines like divine simplicity. To be clear, I am on your side here, but I think this sort of sidesteps the whole issue.
Another fantastic article, Wagner. What a brilliant takedown of Jay's debate tactics. By explaining why challenging his opponents to demonstrate their first principles is foolhardy, you reveal his intellectual dishonesty.
W
Christian, you have confused indemonstrable metaphysical first principles with the demonstrable credibility of divine revelation. The principle of non-contradiction is self-evident; the claim that God revealed a particular religion is not simply declared a first principle and exempted from proof.
Catholic faith rests upon God’s authority, but reason must first establish the motives of credibility by which His revelation and Church are identified. Remove that demonstrability and every sect can call its own assumptions “first principles.” That does not defend the Faith—it makes rational certainty about the true Faith impossible.
The Thomistic school explains the credibility of divine revelation via discursive reasoning. We seek to prove the existence of God, particularly the Christian God, from first principles common to every man. Certain detractors often comment that the “Thomistic system” cannot give an epistemological account for a system based on first principles. This article addresses these claims and defends the practice of reasoning from these first principles, which is said to be unjustified. The article in no way claims that proving the first principle automatically proves God. It is a response to a neo-transcendentalist line of argumentation that denies the validity of a certain type of argument, because they think that simply presupposing the thing in question amounts to a profound and serious argument. I’m not sure what you’re objecting to here.
Nicholas, my objection is not to reasoning from self-evident first principles; on that we agree. It is to extending their indemonstrability to the identity of divine revelation itself.
The principle of noncontradiction is immediately known. That Christianity—and specifically the Catholic Faith—is God’s revelation must be established through demonstrable motives of credibility. If your article preserves that distinction, then my criticism concerns a misuse of its argument, not the argument you intended.
It’s not my article, and the article never claims that to defend Thomistic epistemology amounts to conclusively defending the Catholic faith. That is an absurd proposition, and I’m confused as to how you could think that the article even attempts to make that point.
Nicholas, your correction is well taken. Upon rereading Wagner’s essay, I agree that I attributed to it a thesis it neither states nor entails. Its subject is the indemonstrability—strictly understood—of metaphysical first principles and their dialectical defense against skepticism, not the sufficiency of those principles to establish the truth of Catholic revelation.
The distinction I raised remains necessary in fundamental theology: the act of faith rests formally upon divine authority, while reason establishes the motives of credibility by which a purported revelation is identified as genuinely divine. But Wagner does not deny that distinction, and therefore my criticism did not engage the argument he was actually making.
I also incorrectly referred to the essay as yours. On both points, I stand corrected and withdraw the objection.
??
Wagner isn't saying that nondemonstrable truths immediately prove thomist doctrines, those issues are alltogether different matters. So I fail to see what is even the point being made by Dyer, if this is his argument
The reason for this is simple. If a science demonstrates in virtue of its principles. Therefore, if a science demonstrated its first principles”
Minor confusion
So the parapetetic axiom is proved in the principle of non contradiction, which is the only first principle, because the intellect has to be operational, which means it has to have knowledge, and that knowledge had to come from the senses? I.e. words themselves, which were taught through the senses? What of a baby? Does it know the principle of non contradiction? How would it know this? A general sense? or is the knowledge of this principle acquired at the age of reason? does an animal know this principle?
By general sense, I think proof of this might be the disturbance of the game of peekaboo
What is the explanation for why or how is it proved (thinking of objectors here) that being is prior to our apprehension about being? is it because the world existed before we did? how do we know that? (pardon a stupid question)
Thank you for addressing Jay Dyer. Very helpful. I was put into a temptation of faith because of the lack of depth of Catholic apologetical debators. I am continually confronted on things like the Trinity by Muslims and atheists and others, even though I focus on economics, because that's what they want to talk about. And Dyer seemed better for the Trinity than any Catholics I'd heard. I try to focus on economics. Tomorrow, regardless, out of charity, I have to discuss the Trinity publicly with a Muslim, and I do feel unprepared.
How did it go??
It went really well https://thevillageeconomy.substack.com/p/this-is-the-trinity?r=2xshou
But this isn’t the point made by Jay - yes he argues that you presuppose your own principle but he also argues that your first principle is superfluous. If Jay grants you the principle of non contradiction you have to demonstrate how that leads to Thomistic doctrines like divine simplicity. To be clear, I am on your side here, but I think this sort of sidesteps the whole issue.