Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Thomas Donovan's avatar

Awesome article. I was very interested to see the third document mentioned, as I was generally confused on the whole idea of a “state of emergency” making it a necessary act.

Francesco Maria Cismondi's avatar

Sorry but don’t agree. Canon 1323 is quite relevant not just for paragraph n. 4, but also for paragraph n. 7: “thought, through no personal fault, that some one of the circumstances existed which are mentioned in nn. 4 or 5”. In this sense it is not true what the Vatican said, since it is not true that the state of necessity “must objectively occur”, because it is sufficient for the SSPX to believe to be in a state of necessity: this implies an important concept that is that the will of the SSPX was in a way coerced even by a state that couldn’t objectively be there. The actual result of this detail is that the excommunications are invalid. Moreover, the article doesn’t consider all the public declarations by don Pagliarani to submit to the Holy Father and, as St. Thomas states, “a schismatic both obstinately scorns the commandments of the Church, and refuses to submit to her judgment”. Doesn’t seem applicable to the SSPX to be honest. You can hate the SSPX but being intellectually honest forces to admit that there is no schism and that the excommunication are invalid.

26 more comments...

Ready for more?